Critique Archive
2013:
Robert Clewis -- The Kantian Sublime and the Revelation of Freedom
Kiyoshi Chiba -- Kants Ontologie der raumzeitlichen Wirklichkeit
critics: Henny Blomme, Christian Onof I, Onof II
author's replies: reply to Blomme, reply to Onof
Jennifer Mensch -- Kant’s Organicism: Epigenesis and the Development of Critical Philosophy
critics: Angela Breitenbach, Hein van den Berg
author's replies: reply to Breitenbach, reply to Van den Berg
2014:
Giuseppe Motta -- Die Postulate des empirischen Denkens überhaupt
critic: Thomas Teufel
author's reply: reply to Teufel
Stefanie Grüne -- Blinde Anschauung: Die Rolle von Begriffen in Kants Theorie sinnlicher Synthesis
critics: Thomas Land, Colin McLear
author's replies: reply to Land, reply to McLear
Land's rejoinder to author's reply
Katerina Deligiorgi -- The Scope of Autonomy: Kant and the Morality of Freedom
critics: Adrian Piper, Jeppe von Platz
author's reply: reply to Piper & Von Platz
2015:
Sally Sedgwick -- Hegel’s Critique of Kant
critics: William Bristow, Sebastian Rand
author's reply: reply to Bristow & Rand
Dalia Nassar -- The Romantic Absolute: Being and Knowing in Early Romantic German Philosophy, 1795–1804
critics: Richard Fincham, Reed Winegar
author's reply: reply to Fincham & Winegar
Kristi Sweet -- Kant on Practical Life: From Duty to History
critics: Stefano Bacin, Kate Moran
author's reply: reply to Bacin & Moran
Corey Dyck -- Kant and Rational Psychology
critics: Andrew Brook, Scott Edgar, Toni Kannisto, Colin Marshall
author's reply: reply to Brook, Edgar, Kannisto & Marshall
Lawrence Pasternack -- Kant on Religion within the Boundaries of Mere Reason
critics: Christopher Insole, Allen Wood part A, Wood part B (Note on Judaism)
author's replies: reply to Insole, reply to Wood
2016:
Lara Ostaric -- Interpreting Schelling: Critical Essays
New Work on Hegel (I): Anton Koch et al. (eds) -- Hegel—200 Jahre Wissenschaft der Logik & Folko Zander -- Herrschaft und Knechtschaft. Die Genese des Selbstbewusstseins in Hegels „Phänomenologie des Geistes“. Ein Kommentar
review essay by Jacco Verburgt
Nathaniel Goldberg -- Kantian Conceptual Geography
critic: Paul Franco
author's reply: reply to Franco
Lucy Allais -- Manifest Reality: Kant’s Idealism and his Realism
critics: Colin Marshall, Colin McLear
author's reply: reply to Marshall & McLear
Sorin Baiasu -- Kant and Sartre. Re-Discovering Critical Ethics
critics: Sacha Golob, Christian Skirke
author's reply: no reply
Robert Pippin -- Die Aktualität des Deutschen Idealismus
critical notice by Dennis Schulting
Courtney Fugate -- The Teleology of Reason: A Study of the Structure of Kant’s Critical Philosophy
critic: Huaping Lu-Adler
author's reply: reply to Lu-Adler
Bryan Hall -- The Post-Critical Kant: Understanding the Critical Philosophy through the Opus postumum
critics: Hein van den Berg, Jeffrey Edwards, Kenneth Westphal
author's reply: reply to Van den Berg, Edwards & Westphal
Allen Wood -- The Free Development of Each: Studies on Freedom, Right and Ethics in Classical German Philosophy
critic: Howard Williams
author's reply: reply to Williams
Fabian Freyenhagen -- Adorno’s Practical Philosophy. Living Less Wrongly
critics: Henry Pickford, Christian Skirke
author's replies: reply to Pickford, reply to Skirke
Colin McQuillan -- Immanuel Kant: The Very Idea of a Critique of Pure Reason
critic: Michael Olson
author's reply: reply to Olson
Omri Boehm -- Kant’s Critique of Spinoza
critics: Sebastian Gardner, Nick Stang
author's reply: reply to Gardner & Stang
2017:
Robert Hanna -- Cognition, Content, and the A Priori
critics: David Landy, Dennis Schulting
author's replies: reply to Landy, reply to Schulting
Christopher Insole -- Kant and the Creation of Freedom. A Theological Problem
critics: Wolfgang Ertl, David Sussman
author's replies: reply to Ertl, reply to Sussman
Silvan Imhof -- Der Grund der Subjektivität. Motive und Potenzial von Fichtes Ansatz
critics: Dietmar Heidemann & Oliver Motz
author's reply: no reply
Sidney Axinn -- Sacrifice and Value: A Kantian Interpretation
critics: Katerina Deligiorgi, Helga Varden
author's reply: no reply
Stephen Palmquist -- Comprehensive Commentary on Kant’s “Religion within the Bounds of Bare Reason”
critics: Christina Drogalis, Ronald Green, Susan Meld Shell, Philip Rossi
author's reply: reply to Drogalis, Green, Shell & Rossi
David Landy -- Kant’s Inferentialism: The Case Against Hume
critics: Anil Gomes, Tim Jankowiak
author's reply: reply to Gomes & Jankowiak
Nicholas Stang -- Kant’s Modal Metaphysics
critics: Jessica Leech, Andrew Stephenson
author's reply: reply to Leech & Stephenson
Guido Kreis -- Negative Dialektik des Unendlichen. Kant, Hegel, Cantor
critics: Franz Knappik, Damian Bravo Zamora
author's reply: no reply
Martin Shuster -- Autonomy after Auschwitz: Adorno, German Idealism, and Modernity
critics: Charlotte Baumann, Robert Hanna, Henry Pickford
author's reply: reply to Baumann, Hanna & Pickford
Dennis Schulting -- Kant’s Radical Subjectivism: Perspectives on the Transcendental Deduction
critics: Paul Giladi, Sacha Golob, Robert Watt
author's replies: reply to Giladi, reply to Golob, reply to Watt
James Conant -- ‘Why Kant is not a Kantian’
critical notices by Sacha Golob, Dennis Schulting
2018:
Pauline Kleingeld -- Kant and Cosmopolitanism
New Work on Kant (I): Dennis Schulting (ed.) -- Kantian Nonconceptualism
review essay by Jessica Williams
New Work on Kant (II): Anil Gomes & Andrew Stephenson (eds) -- Kant and the Philosophy of Mind. Perception, Reason, and the Self
New Work on Hegel (II): Martin Bondeli et al. (eds) -- Krankheit des Zeitalters oder heilsame Provokation? Skeptizismus in der nachkantischen Philosophie
Wayne Waxman -- Kant’s Anatomy of the Intelligent Mind
critics: John Callanan, Colin McLear
author's reply: reply to Callanan & McLear
Efraín Lazos -- Disonancias de la Crítica. Variaciones sobre cuatro temas kantianos
critic: Edgar Valdez
author's reply: reply to Valdez
Alfredo Ferrarin -- Il pensare e l’io. Hegel e la critica di Kant
critics: Elisa Magrì, Guido Frilli
author's reply: reply to Magrì & Frilli
Adrian Piper -- Rationality and the Structure of the Self, second edition
critics: Paul Guyer, Richard Bradley
author's reply: reply to Guyer & Bradley
Richard Eldridge -- Images of History. Kant, Benjamin, Freedom, and the Human Subject
critics: Robert Louden, Alison Ross
author's reply: reply to Louden & Ross
Serena Feloj -- Estetica del disgusto. Mendelssohn, Kant e i limiti della rappresentazione
critics: Alberto Siani, Robert Clewis
author's replies: reply to Siani, reply to Clewis
Alberto Siani -- Morte dell’arte, libertà del soggetto. Attualità di Hegel
critic: Paul Kottman
author's reply: reply to Kottman
New Work on Kant (III): Michela Massimi & Angela Breitenbach (eds) -- Kant and the Laws of Nature
Irad Kimhi -- Thinking and Being
2019:
New Work on Hegel (III): Johannes-Georg Schülein -- Metaphysik und ihre Kritik bei Hegel und Derrida
review essay by Jacco Verburgt
New Work on Kant (IV): Eric Watkins (ed.) -- Kant on Persons and Agency
review essay by Christian Onof
Henry Allison -- Kant’s Transcendental Deduction. An Analytical-Historical Commentary
critics: Michael Friedman, Alison Laywine, Lucy Allais
author's replies: reply to Allais, reply to Friedman, reply to Laywine
2020:
On Sebastian Rödl’s “Self-Consciousness and Objectivity”, Or, The Refutation of Absolute Idealism
New Work on Kant (V): Over een extreem fenomenalistische interpretatie van Kant -- Emanuel Rutten -- Contra Kant. Herwonnen ruimte voor transcendentie
review essay by Dennis Schulting
Hedging Around Objectivity: Reply to De Boer, Blomme, Van den Berg & Spigt
-------